Most Expensive Football Cards Sold on eBay in September 2024

Tales of old quarterbacks and flashy new cardboard

Note: When you click on links to various merchants in this newsletter and make a purchase, this can result in this newsletter earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Last month, we saw Jerry Rice take the “old guy” title as the top former player mixing it up with the current crop of quarterbacks among the top football cards sold on eBay (in August, in that case). That followed a multi-month run for Walter Payton, who slid backwards in terms of big-money cards sold on eBay.

At the top of our “standings” last month, Patrick Mahomes showed up more times than any other player for the second month in a row, with Jordan Love the only other name showing up 10 or more times.

With the new NFL season underway, how much did on-field stories shake up these rankings since then?

Well, just one way to find out! Here are the players who appear more than once on our list of the most expensive football cards sold on eBay during September 2024 (full list at bottom of post):